The Best Buys in Vintage Watches
Where does a watch geek start when looking for some of the best value in vintage watches? We’re going to go through three options to get you started.
JANUARY 22, 2020
The vintage watch market, while incredibly complex and ever in motion, is still a hub for value. It’s not uncommon for enthusiasts to own historically important pieces from prestigious brands for a fraction of the cost of a modern counterpart.
So where does a watch geek start when looking for some of the best value in the vintage watch world? We’re going to go through three options to get you started.
The Rolex Datejust
Credit: Theo & Harris
Our love for the Rolex Datejust here at T&H is long standing, and if you’ve ever spent time with one you surely share it. They’re supremely well-made, incredibly versatile, prestigious and, at 36mm in diameter, sized classically.
As of this publishing, they can be had for anywhere from $3,300 (give or take) on up, depending on rarity and condition, but most don’t exceed $5,000 on average.
Credit: Theo & Harris
Which references should you look out for? The Datejust’s of the 1960’s and 70’s were all part of the 160- series, made up of the 1601, 1603 and the 1600. The 1601 is certainly the most traditional with its fluted gold bezel while the 1603 featured a rugged “engine turned” finish and the 1600 a smooth steel bezel.
Credit: Theo & Harris
Variations within the series are seemingly endless, from blue dials with fluted bezels and Jubilee Bracelets to black dials in two-tone cases on leather straps, and about anything else you can conjure up. If you’re willing to play the 36mm game (and you should be), then there is no doubt a vintage Datejust should be on your list.
Grand Seiko
It’s no state secret that modern Grand Seiko offers some of the best damn value in the world, but vintage Grand Seiko shouldn’t be ignored either. In the world of vintage Grand Seiko, there are really a small handful of models to consider, and all of them pack some serious value.
Credit: The Grand Seiko Guy
The 44GS is a watch that is a legend among Grand Seiko enthusiasts. The model introduced what is known as the “Grammar of Design” to the Grand Seiko lineup. Coined by designer Taro Tanaka, the “Grammar of Design” defined four basic ideas that should be used to develop a watch:
1) All surfaces and angles from the case, dial, hands, and indices had to be designed in such a way that they would be able to reflect light perfectly, best executed via flat edges and perfect geometric shapes.
2) Bezels needed to be simple, two-dimensional faceted curves devoid of any pomp and circumstance, like fluting.
3) All cases and dials needed to be mirror-finished (courtesy of Grand Seiko’s now legendary Zaratsu polishing).
4) No generic round case designs; each reference should feature a case with a wholly unique design and execution both from the others in the line, and from the broader watch world.
The watch clearly encapsulates all of these elements, and then some. With a case diameter of 37mm (but a shorter lug-to-lug length than the Datejust), it wears more traditionally, but the bold impression the case has on the wrist is something worth experiencing no matter what you think about its nominal size. 44GS models start around $3800, which is right on par with the Datejust. Other important references to have a look at are the 62GS (which can be had for about the same money), and the 45GS (which can often be had for under $2,000, making it one of the most value heavy options).
The Patek Philippe Calatrava
Last, but by no means least, we have the Patek Calatrava. I know, when I say “value driven vintage watches,” Patek Philippe is not one of the first brands you think of. But what might shock a lot of you is just how attainable some of the more classical Calatravas can be if you’re willing to go vintage.
Credit: Monochrome
The ultimate place to start is the Patek Philippe Calatrava reference 96, which isn’t just the first Calatrava, but the first timepiece produced by the brand to have a numbered reference. With all that behind it, you’d expect it to be worth some serious money, but because of the watch’s small size, it can often be had between $7-9k (yeah, you can own a Patek for less than a new Submariner). And unlike the others on this list, I do want to emphasize that the 96 is a small watch at 31mm in diameter. If you can live with this, though, then it’s probably one of the best ways to spend your money on vintage dress watches.
Credit: Phillips
There’s also the Patek Calatrava reference 570. At between $13-16k, we’re looking at the higher end of value here, but at 36mm, we’re back in wearability land for most folks. There are a huge range of options to be had in this reference, and while it is undoubtedly a dress watch, there is also little doubt that on the right strap, it can be worn more casually with its center seconds complication. Plus, no matter how you slice it, the 570 is still easily had for under $20k, someplace most modern Calatravas (or, indeed, Pateks in general) simply aren’t seen.
We upload new content every day of the week!







